CUNA
  • Advocacy
    • Priorities we’re fighting for
    • Actions you can take
  • News
  • Learn
  • Compliance
  • Shop
  • CUNA News
    • Policy & Issues
    • CU System
  • Credit Union Magazine
    • Technology
    • Lending
    • Compliance
    • Marketing
    • Management
    • Operations
    • Human Resources
    • Volunteers
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Buyers' Guide
  • Awards
    • CU Rock Star
    • CU Hero
Learn More about Member Value

News

Member Benefits
Learn more
Learn more about the benefits of membership.
Home » A Merger Slowdown
Operations

A Merger Slowdown

The 230 CU mergers in 2010 represent the second fewest in 30 years.

May 1, 2011
Darla Dernovsek
No Comments

New territory

First Community Federal Credit Union, Parchment, Mich., began its strategy of gradually expanding its territory to encompass a broader region in 2006, when it merged with $15 million asset United Savers Federal Credit Union in Battle Creek, Mich., about 30 miles outside the Kalamazoo area where most branches are located.

First Community built on this strategy in 2010 through a voluntary merger with $60 million asset Education First Credit Union, Southgate, Mich., about 140 miles away, and a purchase-and-assumption merger with $120 million asset First American Credit Union, Beloit, Wis., about 250 miles away. The mergers created combined assets of $623 million.

“You know the saying, ‘It’s not good to have all your eggs in one basket,’” says President/CEO Cheryl A. DeBoer. “To some extent, this could be stated as a benefit of growing into new regions. As one region might be experiencing growth in certain areas, another region might be experiencing downturns. That can provide a balance in terms of growth opportunity.”

Technology such as web conferencing, which is combined with periodic face-to-face meetings, supports the transition to a single organization. That allows opportunity to outweigh distance as a merger consideration, even in a purchase-and-assumption merger.

“First American had undergone some stresses related to the economic condition within their membership,” DeBoer said. “We felt the partnership was a good one as our membership base was very similar, along with the culture within our credit unions.”

DeBoer acknowledges that many smaller credit unions want to continue to run independently. “We are seeing, though, with shrinking margins and increased product line demand along with economic and regulatory issues, that it’s becoming increasingly difficult for some small credit unions to thrive,” DeBoer says.

Economies of scale

Credit unions often cite the opportunity to pursue economies of scale as a motivation for mergers, but those savings can prove difficult to realize. Alliant Credit Union, Chicago,
with $7.5 billion in assets, achieves those economies by eliminating redundant expenses, according to President/CEO David W. Mooney.

That philosophy was reflected in mergers in 2008 with $96 million asset Kaiperm Federal Credit Union, Oakland, Calif., which served health-care employees, and in 2010 with
$170 million asset Continental Federal Credit Union, Tempe, Ariz., which served employees of Continental Airlines and U.S. Airways.

Alliant was founded to serve United Airlines employees and now counts more than 150 select employee groups (SEGs) in its membership base.

“In the case of Continental, the credit union’s airline heritage made it attractive,” Mooney says. “The other aspect was that we saw an opportunity to create financial value for our members through merger and integration and elimination of redundant expense.”

 Alliant announced the Continental merger in September 2010 and completed integrating operations in January 2011, retaining five branches and the related staff and some call center positions.

That enabled Alliant to eliminate approximately 80% of Continental’s operating expenses, or about $8 million annually. Mooney says conservative estimates put the merger payback at about 16 months to recover “integration expenses, write-downs to exit leases and contracts, and market value adjustments.”

Disciplined decisions

Mooney says it’s painful to eliminate jobs in a tough economic environment, but it’s essential to capture economies of scale.

“I’m a believer that credit unions need to be a little bit more disciplined about eliminating the redundant expense in mergers,” Mooney says. “Otherwise, the question I would have is, ‘Why bother?’ What’s the advantage of being bigger if you’re not going to capture the economies of scale? It’s imperative if you’re going to serve your members’ interests.”

Continental members gained high deposit rates and below-market loan rates along with strong online and mobile banking services. But Continental members also had to accept the Alliant branch model, which eliminates cash withdrawals and deposits in teller lines, relying on ATMs to supply cash.

“That certainly was unpopular with some of Continental’s members whose primary needs or preferences were cash from a teller,” Mooney says. “But fundamentally that was nonnegotiable because our model is cashless and that’s a big part of why our rates are as good as they are.”

This “thin branch” approach helps Alliant avoid what Mooney describes as an “arms race” to build the most branches. Instead, Alliant targets SEGs that allow the credit union to take advantage of both the affinity with the company and the sponsoring company’s endorsement.

Previous 1 2 3 Next
KEYWORDS credit economies mergers unions
  • Related Articles

    Expect Greater Impact From Online Banking Fraud

    Understand Your Merger Goals

    Strategies for Fading Fee Income

Darla Dernovsek

Innovative CUs Draw Up New Lending Approaches

More from this author

Post a comment to this article

Report Abusive Comment

This Month Payments: Perils and Promise

Payments: Perils and Promise

The payments arena offers new opportunities to connect with members.
Cards Are (Still) King

Cards Are (Still) King

Credit and debit cards still drive the competitive payments market.
Open Banking on its Way

Open Banking on its Way

Prepare for the impact it will have on member relationships and competitive positioning.
App Digital Edition Subscribe

Trending

  • Compliance: New mortgage servicing rules now effective

  • Nussle: Any change to CU tax status would harm consumers

  • Nussle issues statement after NCUA responds to Sen. Hatch

Tweets from @CUmagazine and @CUNA_News

Polls

How often do you talk to the board about compensation?

View Results
More

Champion of America’s Credit Unions

Credit Union National Association is the only national association that advocates on behalf of all of America’s credit unions. We work tirelessly to protect your best interests in Washington and all 50 states. We fuel your professional growth at every level and champion the credit union story at every turn.

More CUNA

  • About
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Recommended Websites

Resources for

  • Credit Union Advocates
  • Leagues
  • Press
  • Vendors